Though nominal gdp targeting produces a fairly high compensating variation conditional on the government spending shock, this shock is estimated to be a relatively unimportant driver of fluctuations. Copyright remains with the holder, but users may download, save and distribute this. Economic fluctuations and growth, international finance and macroeconomics, monetary economics the revival of interest in nominal gdp ngdp targeting has come in the context of large advanced economies. For permission to reprint or post an article, email the. Gdp targeting during 2008, it is quite likely that both the financial crisis and the recession. As in the small scale model, nominal gdp targeting performs best when wages are sticky relative to. Nominal gdp targeting and the taylor rule on an even playing. Gdp, and that stability would be helpful in achieving both price stability and maximum employment over the long run. On the desirability of nominal gdp targeting sciencedirect. On the e ciency of nominal gdp targeting in a large open. This interestrate targeting regime, sometimes compared to economist john taylors famous policy rule, worked rel. These arguments are largely based on the idea that nominal gdp targeting would require less knowledge on the part of policymakers than a traditional taylor rule. The revival of interest in nominal gdp ngdp targeting has come in the context of large advanced economies. In addition, our simulations imply that a nominal gdp targeting rule would produce lower volatility in both inflation and the output gap in comparison with the taylor.
Gross domestic product 2018 millions of ranking economy us dollars tca 190 turks and caicos islands 1,022 kna 191 st. On the e ciency of nominal gdp targeting in a large open economy1 matthew hoelle2 m. Because of a cold, i will be missing an invitationonly event featuring scott sumner. The use of divisia monetary aggregates in nominal gdp.
Jun 19, 2012 the current economic crisis has called into question the role of monetary policy, particularly inflation targeting and its oversight of asset bubbles and supply side shocks. This is because doing so would add history dependence to monetary policy. A case for nominal gdp targeting in india harvard kennedy school. We conclude that to minimize share risk, central banks should target nominal gdp. Nominal gdp targeting provides a way to address both inflation and output stability, without. Charles goodhart might just be the best allaround monetary economist in the world, having made impressive contributions to both monetary theory and the history of monetary theory, to monetary history, and the history of monetary institutions, especially of central banking, and to the theory and, in his capacity as chief economist of the bank of. Values that increase or decrease with price level are called nominal values. This economic brief argues that nominal gdp targeting ultimately would be destabilizing. We study nominal gdp targeting as optimal monetary policy in a model with a credit market friction following azariadis, bullard, singh and suda 2018, henceforth abss. This interestratetargeting regime, sometimes compared to economist john taylors famous policy rule, worked rel.
As in abss, the macroeconomy we study has considerable income inequality which gives rise to a large private sector credit market. Nominal gdp targeting is just another red herring to divide conservative monetary consensus nathan lewis contributor opinions expressed by forbes contributors are their own. The use of a monetary aggregate to target nominal gdp. I have not said much about the taylor rule versus nominal gdp growth targeting debate, in part because if gdp growth is linked to money, i. Take an indicative rate of real gdp growth its longrun trend or potential. Nominal gdp targeting for dummies adam smith institute. Vincent and the grenadines 811 asm 195 american samoa 602 dma 196 dominica 551. Targeting nominal gdp after years of fighting inflation, some are now urging the fed to instead target gdp growth and jobs. Based on these results and practical issues of nominal gdp targeting, such as the possibility of enhancing the severity of stagflation, this paper does not recommend nominal gdp targeting as a. Udara peiris 3 january 31, 2014 krannert working paper series, paper no. Jun 28, 2014 patrick sullivan directed me to a post that is mildly critical of ngdp level targeting, by stephen cecchetti and kermit schoenholtz.
Nominal gdp targeting for developing countries nber. Is nominal gdp targeting a rule policymakers could accept. What is ngdp targeting and what are some arguments for. Many analysts argue that the best guide might be nominal gross domestic product gdp. Given that he is dismissing proposals with wide support in the economics profession including economists as.
Real versus nominal gdp inflation can distort economic variables like gdp, so we have two versions of gdp. Conduct monetary policy set the reference interest rate to keep nominal gdp growth at or close to that. I did research on nominal gdp targeting many years ago and found that such targeting proposals had a number of problems, which i summarized in the paper what would nominal gnp targeting do. The large gap highlights an important aspect of nominal gdp targeting. A change in the price level changes the value of economic measures denominated in dollars. Udara peiris 3 june 3, 20 krannert working paper series, paper no. Charles goodhart on nominal gdp targeting uneasy money. Nominal gdp targeting for developing countries pranjul bhandari, jeffrey a. On the desirability of nominal gdp targeting cato institute.
This may not allow for the fact that the free market equilibrium has changed. Oct 06, 2014 nominal gross domestic product gdp targeting is a type of monetary policy that people like me think would give us a more stable economy than we currently have. Some economists have advocated nominal gdp targeting as an alternative to the taylor rule. On the e ciency of nominal gdp targeting in a large open economy. Aug 12, 2015 this paper evaluates the welfare properties of nominal gdp targeting in the context of a new keynesian model with both price and wage rigidity. Nominal gdp targeting would be subject to errors,revisions. For example, if the nominal gdp has grown 10% and the inflation rate is 3%, the real gdp growth is 7%. Nominal gdp targeting with heterogeneous labor supply. Nominal gdp targeting is the second best rule conditional on three of the four shocks, with the exception being the government spending shock. This paper evaluates the welfare properties of nominal gdp targeting in the context of a new keynesian model with both price and wage rigidity. This is also one reason why the same central bankers are wary of proposals for nominalgdp targeting. Jan 15, 2015 central banks must target growth not inflation.
Nominal gdp can give us a misleading picture of the state of the economy. What is 20 nominal gdp what is 2014 nominal gdp nominal. A policy recommendation to meet the feds dual mandate abstract this paper was written in early december 2014 in response to the federal reserve challenge teams argument for a regime change in the federal reserve to nominal gdp targeting as the appropriate policy to return the. Should the fed stick with the 2 percent inflation target or rethink it. List of countries by gdp nominal from wikipedia, the free encyclopedia gross domestic product gdp is the market value of all final goods and services from a nation in a given year. This column is an obituary to inflation targeting and call for nominal gdp targeting to replace it. Nominal gdp targeting and the taylor rule on an even. Nominal gdp targeting would produce lower than average inflation during a productivity boom. Although a considerable amount has been written on the theory of nominal gdp targeting, fewer studies have examined the practical aspects of nominal.
These arguments are largely based on the idea that nominal gdp target. Ngdp targeting is a monetary policy whereby the tightening or loosening of the money supply is dictated by a target on the nominal gross domestic product. Working paper 2017016b by james bullard and aarti singh. Nominal gdp targeting for developing countries pranjul bhandari and jeffrey frankel harvard kennedy school jan. And it is true that looking at nominal gdp targeting through the prism of the past few years might make such targeting seem less hawkish than inflation targeting a backdoor method of allowing excessive inflation.
The notes in this compilation discuss the relative strengths and weaknesses of inflation visavis nominal gdp targeting. Nominal gdp can be understood as sum of all spending in the economy. Nominal gdp targeting for developing countries sciencedirect. We consider the case for ngdp targeting for midsized developing countries, in light of their susceptibility to supply shocks and terms of trade shocks. Dec 19, 2010 i have not said much about the taylor rule versus nominal gdp growth targeting debate, in part because if gdp growth is linked to money, i. This statistic displays the nominal gross domestic product gdp forecast of the united kingdom uk from 201718 to 202324. Early suggestions of the possible use of monetary aggregates in nominal gdp targeting include feldstein and stock 1993, who showed that the relation between m2 and nominal gdp is sufficiently strong to warrant further investigation into using m2 to influence nominal gdp, as would be relevant to the second approach described above. I am late getting to this, but mark thoma wants to hear the case for nominal gdp targeting. Nominal gross domestic product gdp targeting is a type of monetary policy that people like me think would give us a more stable economy than we currently have. In the spirit of sharing my ideas without my germs, let me offer some thoughts on nominal gdp targeting. Patrick sullivan directed me to a post that is mildly critical of ngdp level targeting, by stephen cecchetti and kermit schoenholtz. The sum is the target rate of nominal income growth. In the us, this strategy would incorporate two other targets. Instead we calculate real gdp, which removes the effects of price changes and shows actual changes in output from year to year.
The case for nominal gdp targeting home mercatus center. Nominal gdp targeting and the taylor rule on an even playing field. Gdp is the monetary value of all of the goods and services produced within a nations borders in a given period of time. Nominal gdp targeting, on the other hand, offers both a politically and. Writing in the afr, economics correspondent jacob greber begins his discussion of the xenophon proposal with the assessment what a stupid idea. Developing countries are better suited for it, however, in light of big supply shocks and terms of trade shocks, such as monsoon rains and oil import price shocks in the case of india.
Comparing nominal gdps from year to year shows the amount an economy has grown or shrunk in dollar amounts, but does not show how the buying power of those dollars has been affected. Gdp targeting in a nutshell, targeting nominal income growth works as follows. For the fed, a target represents a justification for taking action. In particular, a nominal gdp targeting rule would not require real.
The current economic crisis has called into question the role of monetary policy, particularly inflation targeting and its oversight of asset bubbles and supply side shocks. Founded in 1980, the mercatus center is located on george mason univer sitys arlington and fairfax campuses. The case for and drawbacks of nominal gdp targets brookings. Nominal gdp targeting and the monetary policy framework. Nominalgdp targeting federal reserve bank of dallas. The use of divisia monetary aggregates in nominal gdp targeting. These results indicate that nominal gdp level targeting might be worth considering as an alternative framework for monetary policy. Nominal gdp targeting would be subject to errors,revisions and likely inflation posted on september 28, 2015 by notayesmanseconomics one of the features of economic life is that there are a lot more reinventions of old ideas than there are new ones. In particular, we compare the welfare properties of nominal gdp targeting to two other popular. Jan 21, 2016 nominal gdp targeting is just another red herring to divide conservative monetary consensus nathan lewis contributor opinions expressed by forbes contributors are their own.
Pdf the macroshare economy and nominal gdp targeting. Aug 25, 2016 nitpicking on nominal gdp targeting august 25, 2016 john quiggin 49 comments writing in the afr, economics correspondent jacob greber begins his discussion of the xenophon proposal with the assessment what a stupid idea. Several people have asked me to comment on nominal gdp targeting, as recently proposed by scott sumner, christina romer and paul krugman. Nominal gdp targeting as an alternative framework for. In addition, nominal gdp is a less volatile aggregate than the consumer price index and the level of nominal gdp is the relevant indicator for assessing the sustainability of debt. The case for nominal gdp targeting mercatus center. We find that under certain plausible conditions, nominal gdp targeting is indeed. Nov 19, 2011 several people have asked me to comment on nominal gdp targeting, as recently proposed by scott sumner, christina romer and paul krugman.
Nominal gdp could be rising because of higher production, or it could be rising because of higher prices. Gdp targeting does almost as well, signi cantly bettering both an estimated taylor rule as well in ation targeting. On one hand, there is a real inflation risk as the fed is clear that it will be ok with an up to 2. Such targets are adopted by central banks to manage national economic activity.
Download this paper open pdf in browser register to save articles to your library. The objective of this paper is to study the desirability of nominal gdp targeting within the context of a new keynesian model with both price and wage rigidity. Dec, 2012 now, however, the fed has put you in a tight spot. Nominal gdp practice key real verse nominal values prices in an economy do not stay the same. Instead of targeting inflation, central banks would start to target nominal gdp, which is the product of price level as measured.
Oct 16, 2011 targeting nominal gdp after years of fighting inflation, some are now urging the fed to instead target gdp growth and jobs. A nominal income target is a monetary policy target. Clark as the monetary aggregates have become less reliable guides for monetary policy, considerable interest has developed in identifying some other fundamental guide for policy. At the same time, nominal gdp targeting is subject to criticisms, some of which stem from the monetarist tradition. The case for nominal gdp targeting wall street pit. It would replace the bank of englands current monetary policy, inflation targeting. Rather than specifying a fullfledged model for a free floating exchange rate. A nominal gdp target overcomes the knowledge problem better than the taylor rule does and is. Is nominal gdp targeting a european parliament european union. Table of contents table of contentstable of contents april 6, 2020 gdp country charts.
Old debates about the use of rules versus discretion for conducting monetary policy and the efficacy of nominal gross domestic product gdp targeting have recently returned to the forefront of monetary policy discussions. Kitts and nevis 1,011 vut 192 vanuatu 914 wsm 193 samoa 820 vct 194 st. Nominal income aggregates that can serve as targets include nominal gross domestic product ngdp and nominal gross domestic income gdi. For india, in particular, one major exogenous supply shock is the monsoon rains. On the desirability of nominal gdp targeting request pdf. Real gdp values output using the prices of a base year. Early suggestions of the possible use of monetary aggregates in nominal gdp targeting include feldstein and stock 1993, who showed that the relation between. Sep 28, 2015 nominal gdp targeting would be subject to errors,revisions and likely inflation posted on september 28, 2015 by notayesmanseconomics one of the features of economic life is that there are a lot more reinventions of old ideas than there are new ones.
Oped central banks must target growth not inflation. A policy of nominal gdp targeting generally deviates from inflation targeting. Is nominal gdp targeting a suitable tool for ecb monetary. Central banks use a variety of techniques to hit their targets, including. It has an intellectual pedigree that goes back well before the crisis, but even if we just focus on the recent debate over changing fed policy to targeting. Clark as the monetary aggregates have become less reliable guides for monetary policy, considerable interest has developed in iden. Under ngdp targeting, bygones are not bygones and the central bank is compelled to make up for past misses on the path of nominal gdp. Targeting nominal gdp growth by monetary policymakers is equivalent to a restriction on policymaker preferences for an optimality condition derived under rational. The promise of nominal gdp targeting mercatus center. In response to the recent buzz about targeting nominal gdp, goodhart, emeritus professor at the london school of economics and an adviser to morgan stanley along with two morgan stanley economists, jonathan ashworth and melanie baker, just published a critique of a recent speech by mark carney, governorelect of the bank of england, in which. Interest in nominal gdp ngdp targeting has come in the context of large advanced economies. This is meant to account for the fact that one dollar generally has less purchasing power now than it did in the past. Gross domestic product without or before accounting for inflation.
738 1435 716 676 673 804 1490 678 1252 1091 720 217 657 564 1291 593 879 730 955 857 487 72 1305 1379 953 887 1365 1281 696 1134 1286 154 748 1478 856 1286 384 15 1364 168 678 899 662 1089 910 524 872